For those of you who follow this blog, you know that the books I read are very eclectic and often chosen for no reason whatsoever. That was certainly the case with Das Haus in East Berlin, by J. Arthur Heise and Melanie Kuhr. I picked it up on a neighborhood walk at one of those Little Library installations about two blocks from our house. I don’t know who lives there, but they had a number of interesting books for the taking and I took one, a paperback nonfiction book whose story line seemed intriguing to me. I read it in one day, two sittings.
There is a house in Berlin, formerly in East Berlin, built by author Kuhr’s great-grandfather in the early 1930s. They were a German (first), Jewish (second) family, who had lived in Germany for generations. But because they were Jewish, they were not going to live there for long, and her great-grandfather (his name was Simonsohn) sold the property in 1941 to a gentile family, the family of author Heise. Many of the Simonsohn descendants were able to leave Germany (and most, including the author, came to the United States), but her great-grandparents did not leave, and were victims of the Holocaust.
The Heise family lived in the house through World War II (author Arthur Heise was born during this time), but the house was taken by them after the war by the new Communist government (it was one block from the East-West Berlin border) of the DDR.
In 1989, the Berlin Wall came down. And shortly thereafter, a new industry was formed. German lawyers helping former German residents to get their properties in East Germany returned to them. This included Jewish Germans who property was taken from them during the Hitler years, and other Germans who lost their properties during the Communist years.
You see the problem…..who was entitled to the property, or to proceeds from the sale of the property – the family of Arthur Heise, or the family of Melanie Kuhr?
The books is relatively short and a quick read (as you can see from above), with alternating chapters written by the two authors. The first third gives the history of the house from the perspective of the two families, the second third is about the authors’ dealings with each other, and the final third about the ultimate disposition of das Haus. As you can guess, it all turned out all right.
But, the Germans being careful and bureaucratic folks, as we know, it took over ten years (and the dismissal of two sets of lawyers) to accomplish the task.
Perhaps the most interesting factor was the presumption in German law that, if a Jewish owned family sold their house during Nazi times, they were not given full value and the “sale” was deemed void and the Jewish family deemed still today entitled to the property. So that was one problem – if the Heise family were to have any claim to the property, it had to be shown that the 1941 transaction was not a sale of property under duress. Another problem was that Arthur Heise’s father, an electrician with his own business, was a member of the Nazi party; they had to prove he was a member of the Nazi party in name only, and that he had not done any Nazi-like things.
They were able to satisfy the authorities and themselves (equally important to both of them) on both of these matters. Heise was a Nazi in order to keep his business and avoid being taken for military duty; the 1941 sale price was, in fact, a market price, and the two families back then, Jew and gentile, were in fact on good terms with each other.
I don’t expect anyone to find or read the book, but if you did, you would not be disappointed.
Last night, after celebrating Mary Peltola’s Alaska win, we watched Ron Howard’s new documentary film, Avedon, on Netflix. It is the story of fashion photographer Richard Avedon, his life and his career. It has received very good reviews, and I agree with them. Well worth watching if only to see the photographs, from his early fashion photographs, his portraits of the well known, his commercial photography, his documentary photography, and his more artistic work, done for galleries or museums.
Okay, I am doing pretty good here. After a spate of “I just didn’t like it” reviews, after which everyone, including myself, began to wonder if I were turning into a curmudgeon (first use of that word in the blog), I have given good reviews to an opera, a book, and a documentary film. I have recovered, it seems.
And not only that, here are two more: (1) a YouTube documentary covering a trip through Libya, a country more interesting than you may think, with a lively capital city, Roman ruins, desert oases, a volcano, ancient carved art work on stones, Berber communities and more, and (2) the first of a two part series on Women during the Third Reich, using only old footage with a new narration. Both of those, too, get high marks.
The world indeed is interesting. But how long will it last?