An Anti-War Post, Plus Pat Boone (“You Made Me Cry, When You Said “Good-bye”, Ain’t That a Shame?”)

Pat Boone

Back to the theory that every day you learn something that surprises you. Yesterday, I learned that Pat Boone, whom I always thought must be about 6’2″, is only 5’9″. You may never have heard of Pat Boone (“Ain’t that a shame, My tears fell like rain”, and “When I lost my baby, I almost lost my mind” – see a theme here?), but when I was a kid….

Pat Boone is now 92, by the way. He used to be much younger.

Let’s move on.

Last night, for the first time in decades, I finished reading Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse Five. I saw a copy on a shelf in the basement and thought I needed to read it. Slaughterhouse Five is a semi-memoir of Vonnegut’s military service during World War II, when he was a German prisoner of war and was being held in an underground storage facility the night the Allies firebombed Dresden. He was unharmed, while thousands and thousands near him were killed and the safe city of Dresden (a beautiful historic city with no military presence, considered off-limits) was obliterated.

It was the third war novel I have recently read, the other two being two novels of Ford Madox Ford’s tetralogy, No More Parades and A Man Could Stand Up, both also being semi-memoirs, but of the First, not the Second, World War. Ford was a generation older than Vonnegut, and British, while Vonnegut was American.

I was struck by both the similarities and the differences between the two authors. The differences would not have been so striking, if it were not for the similarities. I looked up to see if Vonnegut was influenced by Ford, and I was told that critics could not find any connection (and Vonnegut had written a fair amount as to what previous writers had influenced him, and they were mainly comic writers, something Ford Madox Ford certainly was not). But critics have noted the similarities, and if they didn’t find them completely coincidental, found them independently developed from similar (if different) circumstances.

How to explain…..

In the writings of both Vonnegut and Ford, the books were written from the perspective of someone who was in combat many years before, and whose life was materially altered by the experience. But more than that, the books were both written in a stream of consciousness fashion, where time was not treated normally, and events that happened during the war and after were put together helter-skelter, showing what today would be considered as result of PTSD, but then were considered shell-shock or …… I don’t really know.

When you read Ford Madox Ford, you know that he is a brilliant writer. Every word seems crafted; you can see the trouble he must have gone to with every sentence. The problem is that you have no idea what he is talking about. It is like reading an impressionist (or a pointillist) painting. If you look at it closely, although you can see the brilliance with every brush stroke, you don’t know what you are looking at. If you step back far enough, the entire picture becomes clear. (Similar, in my limited mind, to reading most of Faulkner.)

I wanted to make sure that it wasn’t just me, so I looked online at a number of essays about Ford. The advice given by one critic was simply – if you really want to appreciate Ford Madox Ford, you should read each book twice. This is, he said, because it is so confusing to have, in one chapter, or even one long paragraph, time going back and forth, in (as I said) a stream of consciousness fashion, following the thoughts of the very confused protagonist, as he tries to meld his past and his present.

Digression: The Ford tetralogy concerns a wealthy young officer with British troops in France fighting the Germans, trying to figure out his life as a young scion of the British upper classes, trying to reconcile his unhappy but proper life with his unfaithful upper class wife, and his dream to be with the woman he really loves, a middle class (if that) school teacher waiting for his return. His family and close associates do not blame him for finding love outside his marriage, but find it unacceptable that the object of that love is not a member of their social grouping. End of digression.

Vonnegut’s writing is much lighter. His vocabulary is smaller, his sentences are shorter, his paragraphs are more clearly defined, there are more empty spaces on the page as time periods and topics change. But the sense is the same. It is the story of Vonnegut himself, who is the unnamed narrator, and of Billy Pilgrim, who served with him and whose story line is followed for much of the book. Pilgrim, a soldier who never should have been a soldier, was captured by the Germans and present during the firebombing of Dresden. Back home, he was a successful optometrist, but a man subject to the memories of war and to his adventures of being shanghaied by aliens from the far away planet of Tralfamadore, and kept there naked for long periods of time under a dome in a Tralfamadorian zoo. The green residents of Tralfamadore “see” the world in four dimensions – not only our three, but in the additional dimension of “time” which, in their case, means that they see the past, the present and the future all together at all times. Time, to them, is not chronological; it is static. It is always every time.

Billy Pilgrim (and yes, he does spend time in mental hospital) can instantaneously, go from his early childhood, to his time in the war, to his life after the war, to his time in the far away zoo, at a moment’s notice, back and forth, time and time again.

So what is it that led both authors, each of whom waiting more than a decade (two in Vonnegut’s case) to write about their World War experiences, to independently come upon time distortion as the chief element of their story lines? I guess it was because the time abroad in combat was so unlike the time spent in the rest of their lives that it just didn’t fit ordinary chronology; it seemed like a separate life, both long gone and right there. So, Ford’s protagonist, Christopher Tietjen, kept leaving his present condition (office just behind the front lines in France) to dig into his past and confront the problems of his future, and Vonnegut’s Billy Pilgrim left his present condition as upstate New York optometrist behind as he thought about his time during the war and his time, out of time, in that zoo light years away.

And here we are today, with stories of American military personnel coming home from combat or semi-combat situations (Vietnam might be a long time ago, but Iraq, Afghanistan and the Persian Gulf are not) in terrible psychological condition, scarred by their experiences. On the planet of Tralfamadore, by the way, there is no war; the planet exists in perfect peace. But it hasn’t been that way all along; there were times of great war. And, although Billy Pilgrim can not see it, the Tralfamadorians live in the period of war at the same time that they live in their period of peace.

They also, by the way, know how the universe is going to end. It is going to be by an accident of a young engineer, who pushes the wrong button and explodes everything everywhere. The book doesn’t say when that will occur – but it doesn’t really matter, because it is occurring right now in the four dimensional world of the Tralfamadorians, and after it occurs, nothing really changes.

These are all meant to be strongly anti-war books, showing that the wars themselves, as well as the aftermaths of those wars, are irrational and disruptive and, I guess, normal.

As I said yesterday, this is first day of the fifth year of this blog. To quote Kurt Vonnegut….”so it goes”.


One response to “An Anti-War Post, Plus Pat Boone (“You Made Me Cry, When You Said “Good-bye”, Ain’t That a Shame?”)”

Leave a Reply